Comments on Jim Wallace "Rights overkill isn't majority view", 13/10/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26200400-5013480,00.html
Wallace shows the real reasons of that report's "finding" and its recommendations.
That report completely misrepresent what is needed in Australia and what Australians want.
There is no need for a bill of rights in Australia at all.
If any of the recommendations in that report is accepted, it will make Australia a worse place to live and lower the welfare of Australians.
Showing posts with label bill of rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bill of rights. Show all posts
2009-10-13
2009-10-10
Argument against a bill of rights by Paul Kelly
I commented yesterday or the day before on a report of the release of the government commissioned report on a bill of rights and argued against the idea.
Today Paul Kelly has two articles, including one with another person, that show problems with the report and its recommended approaches. See:
Paul Kelly: "Human rights report poisoned chalice", 10/10/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26188812-12250,00.html
Paul Kelly and Chris Merritt: "Human rights charter a recipe for chaos as Frank Brennan cites 'enormous problems'", 10/10/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26189707-601,00.html
Kelly is an experienced political commentator and the editor at large of the Australian.
Today Paul Kelly has two articles, including one with another person, that show problems with the report and its recommended approaches. See:
Paul Kelly: "Human rights report poisoned chalice", 10/10/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26188812-12250,00.html
Paul Kelly and Chris Merritt: "Human rights charter a recipe for chaos as Frank Brennan cites 'enormous problems'", 10/10/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26189707-601,00.html
Kelly is an experienced political commentator and the editor at large of the Australian.
2009-10-09
No need for a bill of rights in Australia
Comments on Frank Brennan “A fairer go for all”, 9/10/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,26183726-5013480,00.html
Are human rights really issues in Australia? The answer is very likely to be no. Then why is the fuss about a bill of rights?
It is likely the fuss about a bill of rights is due to some extreme leftists to push their own agenda at the expenses of the freedoms of all people. They want people’s freedom taken away and dictated by judges. They want people live in fear.
There is no need for a bill of rights to shackle people in Australia. If there is any problem, then the elected people in government and parliament can deal with them through legislations.
A fair go can be created within the existing legal framework without resort to a bill of rights. To the contrary, such a bill is more likely to create inequality by taking away people’s freedom unnecessarily. As a result, such a bill will suffocate innovations. It will reduce Australians’ well fair.
All Australians are better off without a bill of rights. Any attempts to have one should be opposed by Australians.
Are human rights really issues in Australia? The answer is very likely to be no. Then why is the fuss about a bill of rights?
It is likely the fuss about a bill of rights is due to some extreme leftists to push their own agenda at the expenses of the freedoms of all people. They want people’s freedom taken away and dictated by judges. They want people live in fear.
There is no need for a bill of rights to shackle people in Australia. If there is any problem, then the elected people in government and parliament can deal with them through legislations.
A fair go can be created within the existing legal framework without resort to a bill of rights. To the contrary, such a bill is more likely to create inequality by taking away people’s freedom unnecessarily. As a result, such a bill will suffocate innovations. It will reduce Australians’ well fair.
All Australians are better off without a bill of rights. Any attempts to have one should be opposed by Australians.
2009-08-27
No need for a bill of rights in Australia
Comments on ABC report “Rights charter the triumph of elitism: Howard”, 27/08/2009, http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2009/08/27/2668011.htm?section=justin
I don't agree there should be a bill of rights. Australians have been quite content with what they have now, then why do we want an unnecessary bill that will put undue constraints to people? Some people really want to control other people and want to take away the rights of other people and that is a bad idea and should not be supported.
While I may not necessarily agree with some policies of the former Howard government, but I totally agree with Howard on the issue of the rights bill. I think he is right and those advocating for that bill in Australia are completely wrong.
I don't agree there should be a bill of rights. Australians have been quite content with what they have now, then why do we want an unnecessary bill that will put undue constraints to people? Some people really want to control other people and want to take away the rights of other people and that is a bad idea and should not be supported.
While I may not necessarily agree with some policies of the former Howard government, but I totally agree with Howard on the issue of the rights bill. I think he is right and those advocating for that bill in Australia are completely wrong.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)