Welcome to Dr Lincoln's blog

Welcome for visiting my blog. Hope you enjoy the visit and always welcome back again. Have a nice day!
Showing posts with label Chinese culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chinese culture. Show all posts

2016-06-01

China still searching for an effective governance system

Comments on Neil Thomas "The Cultural Revolution will not be revived", 1/06/2016

The statement by the author that “‘What the Cultural Revolution did was to teach the Party not to trust its own people’”, does not seem to be a correct characterisation of the Party’s official line. The party’s official line on the key lessons from the Cultural Revolution has been to prevent excessive personal power and authoritarian at the expense of collective leadership style, at all levels, particularly at the very top level of party leadership. It was Mao’s huge popularity with the people and with people’s trust through the revolutionary struggle against Guomingdang regime led by Jiang Jieshi and the establishment of the PRC that made it possible for Mao to launch the Cultural Revolution in the mid 1960s.

However, personal power has the power of addiction, not just in China but also in the west (e.g. JH’s stay as the prime minister until he lost his seat and the changes to prime ministership in the past few years in Australia, as good examples), even though the Communism system has made it much easier to occur. The person, whoever is on the top, would like to continue that power.

Having said that, China has developed and established a system of power transition at the party’s very top, as the past three transitions indicate. It will still be a long way to go for China to have a complete system where power transition is not just a matter for the elites but the people to have a true and more effective democratic voice in deciding who will be the leader or in the leadership team.

No system is perfect and that is why we have see the Trump factor in the USA now and surprises many people have and have expressed worldwide.

The above mentioned changes in the prime ministership in Australia, in conjunction with the difficulties for the government to carry out much needed reforms to further raise living standard and improve equality, also reflect some shortcomings in the west system.

China is still searching for an effective and stable system of governance. How long it will take to have it is a question of interests by many.

2016-03-15

What is "New Confucianism"

Comments on Niv Horesh "Understanding China’s rise", 14/03/2016

While I have apparently seen signs of China adopting some of of revival of Confucianism, I am not sure what the core concepts of the so called New Confucianism.

Yes, Confucianism played an important role for about 2000 years in the Chinese history. But there were also many crises over that period, typified by inter dynastic changes as well as intra dynastic upheavals. Those also included, from period to period, multi states at times.

The Chinese Communists, as well as the May Fourth movement, for a long period were probably against Confucianism.

Is the New Confucianism new stage in terms of reconciling the traditional Confucianism with the current Chinese Communism (Confucianism with Chinese characteristics)?

Or is the New Confucianism a blind of a number of main ancient Chinese philosophies with Confucianism as the core, then all that subject to the current Chinese Communism?

Or is the current Chinese leadership using Confucianism to present a historically and relatively prosperous, well governed Eastern (Chinese) image to facilitate its narratives of China’s rise, a return to its ancient place of a more advanced country?

2010-05-27

Different referencing styles

Comments on Peter Friedman “Plagiarism and China’s future economic development”, 26/05/2010, http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2010/05/26/plagiarism-and-chinas-future-economic-development/

I acknowledge that there are fundamental differences in values placed on community/country relative to individuals between China and East Asian countries as compared to West countries and that has been embedded in the education system.

There is no doubt about it in my mind and I interpret that as part of the differences in values between the two societies. I also expect that difference may play a role in shaping the future average of the “value” system for human beings.

In that sense, Peter Friedman has made an important contribution by pointing that out and highlighted.

However, that does not mean the whole education system in East Asia and China in particular is based on plagiarism and non-acknowledgement of inventions and ideas. That would be a gross over simplistic presentation and highly misleading.

I can just use two or three most famous and well known examples to show why that presentation is problematic and wrong. I guess most people with enough knowledge of China are likely to know Confucius, Marxism, Mao Zedong thought, including historical, foreign and indigenous ideas.

Few Chinese would dare not to acknowledge them and do plagiarism on them.

They show that the Chinese, even under communism, acknowledge property rights.

Some high profile plagiarism cases in the Chinese academic circle or at large are roundly firmly condemned in China, especially by many academic staff and intellectuals including students that can be seen from internet social or academic websites.

They are a disgrace, abnormal and represent a tiny element in Chinese intellectuals. They are equated to crime equivalent, in my view.

Having said that, I would like to argue that there is also a difference in the emphasis of referencing. While there is a tendance of insufficient referencing in some or most papers by Chinese authors, there is an equal tendance of “over” referencing by some western authors, in my view. Some of the references are unhelpful and probably irrelevant.

Referencing is seen as very important, especially for less well known authors so they “have” to show they have done enough research and are on top of the materials and the topics. So many publications may not have enough own real materials but use referencing to strengthen their reputation. That can be a potential problem for research, development and advance.

Of course, there is an equal danger in insufficient referencing on the other hand.

In short, I am not saying that Peter Friedman is completely wrong and as I said he made a useful contribution in understanding. But it should perhaps need to be pointed out what he presented is a small part of a whole and a partial story, although some difference in referencing is likely to firstly and strongly felt by people from the west or who are used to western style referencing, if one is observing enough.

2010-04-30

System of social governance in China

Comments on Tom Cliff “China’s partnership of stability in Xinjiang”, 23/04/2010, http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2010/04/23/chinas-partnership-of-stability-in-xinjiang/

I would say that social governance in China is likely to somewhere in between the social contract and Confucius system.

That applies to both family and government.

The view of social contract is probably leaning on the too ideal side to be the reality, while the Confucius system has been clearly out of date since a long time ago.

2009-11-17

Let economic reforms and evolution do the job in China

Comments on Dan Ryan “Hu Jintao, tear down that Mao”, 17/11/2009, http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/world/hu-jintao-tear-down-that-mao/story-e6frg6ux-1225798347631

In most cases, evolution is better than revolution. That also applies to East Europe.

Besides the China way and the East Europe way, there should be other ways that are likely better.

But it may be true that the evolution in China is slow.

However, one should not forget that China suffered a long period both domestic chaos and wars, and invasions by others before the Chinese Communists came to power in 1949. It is by no means sure that tearing down Mao too quickly would or will be good for China.

An orderly transition, starting from the economy and then gradually to other areas, may not be a bad thing for China after all. Given its size, it is not bad for the region either.

What China has been pursuing is pragmatic not ideological in that sense. One should not lose the context.

2009-07-20

Who is trying to fool others?

Comments on David Burchell “The great gall of China has us fooled”, 20/07/2009, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,25805432-5013479,00.html

Whether the China experts that Burchell talked about have fooled us or not, or whether they have claimed a false moral high ground or not, remain to be seen. However, one thing is certain that Burchell is trying to claim the even higher moral ground.

It is a bravery act, one against many experts. It is commendable on this ground.

One, however, may want to see if David Burchell is trying to claim the moral high ground of the glorious power of past British imperialism. If that is what Burchell tries to do, he may have lost that battle before he even started, since the United Kingdom itself has long given up that status.

Zhao’s book may be useful in understanding some very limited aspects of China at a particular time of Chinese history. There are, however, many valuable Chinese books, especially history. In that context, Zhao’s book is a drop of water in the ocean and it should be understood in that context. Using that book may or may not help Burchell’s cause.

If Burchell wants to claim a moral high ground relating to Chinese issues, it may help if he understands more Chinese books and history and culture.